So, About the Government...


My favorite holiday would probably have to be New Year's, primarily because the television is better than 24-hour marathons of A Christmas Carol, A Christmas Story, It's a Wonderful Life and the more modern Elf. Also, the parties are much more fun, and the merriment is always far from tired because the whole point of New Year's Eve is to bid adieu to the old and welcome the new. New Year's has all of the nostalgia of a tradition like Christmas with none of the overused decorations and caroling, and it comes across as a much more universal theme than the vast and varied faces of Christmas. Of course, to many, New Year's hardly compares to the ritualistic, fervent unwrapping of presents and yuletide cheer boasted by Christmas. As for me, I couldn't tell you what presents I received the year before last, but I could definitely tell you where I was the instant that the ball dropped in Times Square.

Whose Side Are You On, Again?


By R.J. Matson of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch (Published 12/19/2009)

This cartoon calls out Senator Joe Lieberman's seemingly-perpetual opposition to the health care reform bill. The Democratic party, being the "chef" responsible for creating the an omelet (the health care reform bill), appears frustrated after wasting hundreds of eggs and tossing out the Medicare buy-in and the public option completely to suit Lieberman's tastes only to hear that he is now allergic to eggs (equating to being allergic to the entire idea of the bill). The cartoonist's message is that Joe Lieberman's continuous acts as an "independent Democrat" against the bill is needlessly slowing down the process of reform without good reason. I most definitely agree with this message in that Lieberman's opposition is consistently executed with out-of-the-blue timing and out-of-his-mind logic. He hinted about supporting the Medicare buy-in, then waited patiently as the issue underwent debate before torturing his liberal colleagues with a declaration to adamantly oppose it. It seemed as though, no matter what attempts at compromise the Democrats could cook up, Lieberman had made a decision to hinder the bill long before his votes began swinging to the right. If not for this type of opposition within the Democratic ranks, the Senate bill that passed would have greatly resembled the House bill and expedited the reform process that much more.

"Daddy, You Won the Nobel Peace Prize"


By Pat Bagley of The Salt Lake Tribune (Published 12/13/2009)

This cartoon addresses Obama's comments in his recent Nobel Peace Prize acceptance speech dealing with his decision to call for 30,000 more troops in Afghanistan. The cartoon depicts the President and an armed soldier wearing military camouflage while (somewhat hypocritically) displaying the Nobel Peace Prize and a peace sign, respectively. The soldier suggests adding the comments about "the duality of man" into Obama's Oslo speech. The cartoonist's message is that the aforementioned statements were merely a forthright rationalization for the surge under a false guise of peaceful intent, and (plainly) that the President is a hypocrite. Acknowledging that this is in the typical American fashion, I have to disagree with the cartoon's message. Had the President not said something about the surge, it would have spoken volumes about hypocrisy in the administration. However, Obama's choice to acknowledge the irony was a stroke of rhetorical genius. Short of refusing the prize entirely (which, let's face it, would've made a lot more people angry), including his status as a war-president in the speech was the only way to remove that arrow from the quiver of Obama's opponents. Obama did not lobby for the Prize, it was awarded to him by no force of his own. Our President may be a lot of things, but a hypocrite is not one of them.

Be Good for Goodness' Sake!


I'm absolutely fine with the display of religious symbols on public property during the holidays. Now, this may be partially due to the fact that I'm never on any public property during the holidays, but the principle of it would only be troubling to anyone who has a problem being pragmatic. Yes, seemingly contrary to my previous posts advocating separation of church and state, I'm not going to get militant about this. Christmas has become so commercialized that it's hardly a religious holiday at all (considering that it started out as a Pagan holiday, it's only fitting that every religion should grab a piece of the pie). The colorful lights are almost universally received as aesthetically pleasing at the very least, and one taking a stand against a publicly-displayed menorah because of its religious connotations makes about as much sense as one lodging a complaint with the Louvre about the Mona Lisa because he disagrees with Leonardo da Vinci's beliefs. The Constitution states that you can still believe what you want to believe regardless of what the rest of America parades around in front of you. There is no doubt that the secular have their resolve tested just as much as the religious do; it takes just as much faith to believe in nothing as it does to believe in something, especially in a Christmas-clad America. Hang up your menorahs and your crosses and set up your life-sized displays of the manger and birth of Christ. Deck the city halls with whatever you want; just don't get upset when someone you disagree with does the same.

What's the Deal with Healthcare?


The health care bills as passed in the House and as debated in the Senate have some incremental differences and some greater ones. Both bills mandate that individuals must receive some form of insurance or face a financial penalty (though they differ slightly on how that penalty is calculated). Both bills specify the creation of an insurance exchange for the purpose of expediting the process of comparing policy prices and benefits, but the House bill outlines a federally-run exchange with the possibility of state-run systems (given federal approval). The Senate bill proposes that states maintain their own exchanges with the option of combining their individual systems into regional ones at their own discretion (without federal interference). Both bills propose the establishment of public, government-run insurance plan that would force competition with private insurance companies, but the Senate bill includes a provision allowing states to adopt legislation opting out of the plan whereas the House bill does not. The bills' provisions for the allotment of tax credits to pay for plans differ very little, with the only noticeable change being the Senate bill's reduction of the window for subsidies for small businesses from 2015 to 2013. Both bills expand the scope of Medicaid, but the House bill would completely cover approximately one million more people for one year less than the Senate bill. The larger gaps in the bills are generally where one would expect the party lines to be drawn; the Senate bill would maintain insurance companies' immunity from federal anti-trust laws while the House bill would strip it away. The House bill is staunchly expels even the most remote possibility of abortion funding from the public plan and any plan purchased with a subsidy, while the Senate bill conceptually segregates funds and thus allows abortion coverage in both the public and private options. The House bill allows illegal immigrants to purchase insurance from the exchanges while preventing them from receiving federal subsidies to do so, whereas the Senate bill prevents illegal immigrants from purchasing insurance from the exchanges altogether. The House bill's projected results would have a greater scope (and, subsequently, cost) than the Senate bill. With more recent movements in the Senate debate, however, the Senate bill has also undergone an expansion in women's care with the passing of the Mikulski amendment (namely dealing with preventive testing for women). Last Thursday, Senator McCain, fearing that diverting funding from Medicare would hinder the program's ability provide quality care for seniors, moved to strip the Medicare cuts from the bill; if carried out, the bill's financial solidarity would have been gravely endangered—possibly sending the bill back to the Senate Finance Committee to be reshaped entirely. McCain's proposal was defeated, however, indicating that reform is closer now than it has ever been before.