The A-Word Rears Its Ugly Head


Health care reform has met with another hangup that has left House Democrats split. The unavoidable issue of abortion has finally wormed its way into a recent health bill dealing with the possibility of government-issued health insurance subsidies being used to pay for the procedure. Though the bill explicitly states that such a sequence of events may never legally occur (except in cases of rape, incest, or where the mother's life is endangered as per the Hyde Amendment), many pro-life lawmakers remain dissatisfied with good reason; there is absolutely no way to clearly define what part of a subsidy pays for what part of a health insurance policy. Thus, though the bill remains likely to pass in spite of the issue surfacing, there remains all-around dissatisfaction with Congress's most dreaded impasse at its heart: morality. Logically, passing the bill with the current language will do nothing but stop the concept of the public funding of abortion. Also logically, passing the bill with the proposed language that subsidies may only be used to pay for policies that do not cover abortion would exacerbate the issue and inevitably deny women even the Hyde Amendment's specific cases of acceptably-funded abortion. Personally, I understand where the pro-life Democrats are coming from. The subsidies included in the bill will unequivocally make government ease the process of receiving abortions. However, the language that they are proposing simply defuses the purpose of the subsidies altogether by narrowing the scope of their legal application. To me, it equates to the hysteria over "death panels" that we have only recently begun to bury. If a woman chooses an insurance policy that does not cover abortion so that she may maintain eligibility for a government subsidy and her life is threatened by the birth of her child, does not the encouragement of the government for her to undergo the risky pregnancy also equate to state-sanctioned murder if she dies?

0 Response to The A-Word Rears Its Ugly Head

Post a Comment