Yeah, No Kidding



By Walt Handelsman of Newsday (Published 11/13/2009)

The cartoon deals with the recent decision of Attorney General Eric Holder to prosecute Khalic Sheik Mohammed and four other alleged September 11th conspirators in a Manhattan federal court as opposed to a military commission. A jury pool of people sporting various pieces of patriotic and anti-terrorist apparel awaits the process of jury selection preceding the 9/11 trial as a lawyer points out that the process may take a while. This communicates the idea that, though the signs may not be as obscure as those in this cartoon, it is nearly impossible to find a jury that will carry out the trial in an unbiased and fair manner (the likelihood being that any group selected will automatically decide that the defendants are guilty before the trial even begins). Though I agree with the legal rationale behind Holder's decision to prosecute this case out of a slow and ineffective military commission system, I can easily agree with this cartoon's message as well. Mohammed and his cohorts had already been found guilty on the day the planes hit; the idea of a "fair trial" is completely undermined by the "guilty until proven innocent" mentality that such a painful trial will undoubtedly stir up. At this point the legal system is simply going through the motions. It may seem somewhat admirable that Holder would uphold the rigid justice system outlined by the Constitution, but the truth is simply that the civil trial will produce a lengthier sentence in a shorter amount of time than the military commission would. Holder has decided to prosecute less militarily significant defendants (i.e. the attackers of the USS Cole) in commissions than this, yet the main motivation for those decisions was legal rather than moral. And so this trial may be tainted by patriotism, but perhaps this is one of those rare cases in which the end inexplicably justifies the means.

0 Response to Yeah, No Kidding

Post a Comment