Not the Time


This editorial published in The New York Times on 3/12 criticizes the Senate push to block the Environmental Protection Agency's ability to limit greenhouse gases via the authority granted to it by the Clean Air Act. The House has already passed a bill proposing a national cap on greenhouse gases, but the Senate is presenting resistance. The author discusses the two primary bills aimed at limiting the EPA's scope. The first, championed by Lisa Murkowski (a Republican of Alaska), would not only completely block the EPA's authority to enforce the Clean Air Act, but would officially reject the EPA's finding that "greenhouse gases are a danger to public health and welfare," as well (effectively invalidating one of the primary scientific aspects that the agency's authority is based upon). The second bill, proposed by John Rockefeller (Democrat of West Virginia), only limits the EPA's authority with regards to stationary sources (i.e. power plants and manufacturing facilities); the agency would be allowed to enforce emissions caps from all other sources as planned. The author maintains that the senators are fearful of industry's claims that the EPA will abuse its authority, a claim that the author believes is blown far out of proportion.

I disagree with the ultimate point of this article, though I can't say that it will matter. Lisa Murkowski's bill would stir up a storm of controversy once again as to whether or not greenhouse gases are actually harmful to anything; the bill is extreme in its ambition, and will go nowhere because of a lack of the willingness of the Senate to support its high stakes. John Rockefeller's bill is perfectly measured for the economic motivation behind blocking the EPA's expanded use of the Clean Air Act for the time being, and it is just moderate enough to pass through the Senate floor; this bill will, unfortunately, also go nowhere, because Obama would veto it the second it hit his desk. Expanding the EPA's authority via the Clean Air Act was Obama's safety catch to begin with in the event that a comprehensive climate bill was not passed through Congress by this point in time. Climate change must certainly addressed, but using the Clean Air Act (which was never intended to target greenhouse gases) as a blunt enforcer will wreak economic havoc. If the EPA regulates stationary sources, the fears of the economic repercussions "natural gas dash" and other climate-change band-aids will be realized. Demand for low-emission power and technology will rise faster than production's ability to supply it. Electricity prices will rise as a result. The next economic jab would be twofold: consumers would suffer directly from increasing prices for electricity, and businesses and employers would struggle to create jobs (and possibly even continue into layoffs) to deal with heightened electricity expenditures. Climate change should be addressed comprehensively and focus on common ground rather than extremes, and the EPA's untempered regulation of greenhouse gases is the last thing America needs in a recession.

0 Response to Not the Time

Post a Comment