It's like a lottery...
This article from TIME.com (which seems to be about as opinionated as an editorial would be) deals with the Supreme Court's recent move of adding the Skinner v. Switzer case to its docket for its next term. Skinner was convicted of bludgeoning his girlfriend to death as well as stabbing her two mentally-handicapped children to death in 1993. He was sentenced to the death penalty. Skinner then appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, a notably conservative court, in an attempt to have some evidence tested for DNA. The Court rejected his appeal. Skinner then sued on the grounds that the prosecutors' refusal to test the evidence violated his right to due process of the law. The Court agreed to hear the case on May 24th, staying Skinner's execution an hour before it was scheduled to proceed. The author maintains that the case should not have needed to be pushed this far up the chain of judicial authority (stating that the court "should rule that people accused of capital crimes can use federal civil rights laws to obtain the DNA evidence they need to prove their innocence"), and that it is likely that Skinner is innocent. The author also cites an interestingly strong opinion written in the past by Justice Scalia indicating that he seems to think that the proven innocence of a death-row inmate doesn't matter after he has been convicted (but I'm fairly certain this would be differently interpreted in context, because, ideology aside, it doesn't seem to make logical sense).
The media has definitely been touting this case with Skinner pitted as an innocent soul dramatically saved instants away from his gritty, wrongful, government-sponsored execution (with the clever manipulation of some prudent legal defense team, no doubt). I'm looking at it as more of a double-edged sword; for anyone who researches the case, it honestly seems like DNA evidence is the only thing the prosecutors didn't have to convict Skinner with. I agree with the author's statement as to how the Court should rule in the interest of those accused of capital crimes, as the stakes are undeniably higher for such people. The court that denied Skinner's appeal can't really be faulted, either; though few appeals have as sound a basis as Skinner's, most all of these rejected appeals are backed up by enough evidence that the trial was fair and the conviction was just. So, to summarize that facet of my opinion, it's great that this case will be heard, but it's a shame they couldn't find someone who had more of a shot at being legitimately innocent. However, the author goes on to attack the death penalty itself, which I am fairly certain lends itself to a much larger gray area. The idea of a Kafka-esque trial and execution of an innocent man is chilling, to say the least, but, even if the death penalty does not act as a deterrent, it remains a strong bargaining chip tool used by prosecutors to goad those who could likely kill again into pleading guilty for their crimes. Furthermore, in many cases, murderers who have been sentenced to life without parole in states lacking the death penalty kill other prisoners or prison guards during their sentence, and walk away with nothing more than another life sentence. As such, I'm not utterly against the death penalty and, though I hope the Court extends the right to DNA evidence to those accused of capital crimes, I'm not expecting Hank Skinner to hop off of death row next fall.
The media has definitely been touting this case with Skinner pitted as an innocent soul dramatically saved instants away from his gritty, wrongful, government-sponsored execution (with the clever manipulation of some prudent legal defense team, no doubt). I'm looking at it as more of a double-edged sword; for anyone who researches the case, it honestly seems like DNA evidence is the only thing the prosecutors didn't have to convict Skinner with. I agree with the author's statement as to how the Court should rule in the interest of those accused of capital crimes, as the stakes are undeniably higher for such people. The court that denied Skinner's appeal can't really be faulted, either; though few appeals have as sound a basis as Skinner's, most all of these rejected appeals are backed up by enough evidence that the trial was fair and the conviction was just. So, to summarize that facet of my opinion, it's great that this case will be heard, but it's a shame they couldn't find someone who had more of a shot at being legitimately innocent. However, the author goes on to attack the death penalty itself, which I am fairly certain lends itself to a much larger gray area. The idea of a Kafka-esque trial and execution of an innocent man is chilling, to say the least, but, even if the death penalty does not act as a deterrent, it remains a strong bargaining chip tool used by prosecutors to goad those who could likely kill again into pleading guilty for their crimes. Furthermore, in many cases, murderers who have been sentenced to life without parole in states lacking the death penalty kill other prisoners or prison guards during their sentence, and walk away with nothing more than another life sentence. As such, I'm not utterly against the death penalty and, though I hope the Court extends the right to DNA evidence to those accused of capital crimes, I'm not expecting Hank Skinner to hop off of death row next fall.
0 Response to It's like a lottery...
Post a Comment